Deloitte Insights
Recent changes to the CIS introduce new anti-fraud rules, reinstate mandatory nil returns for mainstream contractors and place the exemption for payments to local authorities and certain public bodies on a statutory footing.
We explore these updates below and consider their practical implications for businesses.
New CIS anti-fraud rules took effect from 6 April 2026. Under the Finance Act 2026, HMRC can impose a liability where:
Where HMRC makes a determination under either of the above provisions, a penalty of up to 30% of the determined amount may also be charged, although the charge may be mitigated where the taxpayer is forthcoming with disclosing the inaccuracy and cooperates accordingly. Where a company's conduct is attributable to one of its officers, that officer may be made personally liable for a portion of the penalty.
HMRC may also cancel gross payment status immediately under the new rules, with a five-year restriction on reapplying. A right of appeal remains, but an appeal does not preserve gross payment status pending its outcome.
Under the new rules, a liability is not automatically imposed whenever another party in the supply chain defaults. HMRC must establish that, before making the payment, the contractor knew or should have known of the relevant deliberate CIS or PAYE failure. Knew or should have known is not defined but is discussed in HMRC’s guidance as ‘an objective test’. HMRC distinguish between actual knowledge, which in the absence of direct or explicit evidence ‘may be inferred from circumstantial evidence’, and an objective ‘should have known’ test.
For the latter, HMRC considers whether the only reasonable explanation for the circumstances was that the transaction was connected with deliberate CIS or PAYE non-compliance. An unusual or contrived arrangement is not, by itself, sufficient to establish the knowledge condition, although it may contribute to the overall evidence. Examples of potential warning signs identified by HMRC include unusually low prices, unexplained subcontracting layers, requests for payment to third-party accounts and inconsistent invoicing. These indicators must be considered together and in context, rather than treated as individually establishing liability.
By way of a practical example, a contractor engaging a subcontractor at a price materially below the expected market rate might identify through its onboarding checks that payments are being requested to an account belonging to a different entity, while invoices contain inconsistent details or the subcontractor provides unclear explanations about other parties in the labour supply chain. None of these factors may necessarily establish liability in isolation. However, taken together, they warrant further enquiries before payment is made.
The new legislation increases the need for businesses to proactively assess and identify supply chain risk, heightening the importance of robust due diligence and onboarding procedures, including on-going monitoring of subcontractors' compliance status rather than a one-off check at engagement. These measures form part of HMRC's broader direction of travel, focused on tackling non-compliance and fraud across labour supply chains, and align with broader measures such as the VAT domestic reverse charge in construction and increased scrutiny of arrangements involving umbrella companies. Taken together, they represent a continued shift towards placing greater responsibility on those higher up the supply chain to ensure compliance.
HMRC have reintroduced the legislative requirement for mainstream contractors to submit a nil CIS return where no payments have been made to subcontractors in the relevant period, reversing the position adopted in 2015 when this obligation was removed to reduce administrative burden.
In practice, the return of the requirement to file nil returns for mainstream contractors is unlikely to have a material impact on existing processes. As HMRC’s Government Gateway for CIS returns automatically issues late filing penalties where no return has been submitted, most contractors (mainstream and deemed) continued to file nil returns rather than repeatedly appeal late filing penalties on the basis of nil returns.
The Government Gateway for CIS returns does not currently appear to distinguish between mainstream and deemed contractors and so the onus will be on the contractor to self-assess their status. For many contractors that should be a simple determination. For cases where HMRC may consider the position to be less clear cut, for example a property investment business that also carries property development works (and the interpretation set out in HMRC’s guidance at CISR12080), the practical outcome is likely to be a continued filing of nil returns.
Local authorities and certain public bodies who become subcontractors under the CIS have always been treated as holding gross payment status by virtue of an Extra-Statutory Concession. This meant that all construction payments made to these bodies could be paid gross. The introduction of a new exemption formalises this practice, providing greater certainty on the application of the CIS for contractors making construction payments to local authorities and public bodies.
Whilst the new exemption should not impact how the CIS operates in practice for affected bodies or those contracting with them, the statutory exclusion of payments to local authorities and public bodies is a helpful clarification. Contractors who contract with local authorities or public bodies should of course ensure that the specific subcontractor they engage falls within the scope of those covered by the new statutory exemption.
For more information or support with any aspect of the CIS please speak to your usual Deloitte contacts or any of the below.
|
Michael Nicholaides Jack Kemp Gabrielle Shepherd |
David Garner Laura Senior |